This still feels a little awkward. Maybe someone can help with a line or two? E.g. 2nd verse 4th line? And I think it needs another verse to make the point of the first line. I dunno, I'm just stuck...
~ ~ ~
You were too crazy to be loved
But it came so easy anyhow
I didn't know which way was up
But you had the song and I sang it loud
So when you called the other night
I got up from my dusty grave
Caught the faintest trace of light
Brushed a cobweb and breathed your name
-Chorus
There is no need to say
We can't relive the day
But I'll ask you to stay
Anyway
Say you'll stay anyway
I've got nothing now to claim
In all the sweetness that is you
But every moment calls your name
And every lie is a lover's truth
I must be just as crazy as you
But I don't really seem to care
We can't make an old thing new
But it's cold as hell in that grave over there
(Chorus x2)
If it's too much to ask
We can both wear a mask
Just say you'll stay
Anyway
Say you'll stay anyway
~ ~ ~